Daughters Of The Deer – Danielle Daniel

READ FOR BOOKCLUB
Chosen by Jodie

Danielle Daniel imagines the lives of her ancestors in the Algonquin territories of the 1600s, a story inspired by her family link to a girl murdered near Trois-Rivières in the early days of French settlement.
Marie, an Algonkin woman of the Weskarini Deer Clan, is asked by her chief to marry a Frenchman to cement their alliance with the French against the Iroquois and the British. This is the story of Marie and her first born Jeanne, both caught up in the long history of violence against Indigenous women and the deliberate disruption of First Nations culture.

The deer have four legs like the four directions one must follow to be a strong Algonkin … We are responsible for the waters and the lands that nourish us. Because of these important responsibilities we can hear Earth’s heartbeat, the changes of its season and its rhythms.

Click the arrow to read each person’s full review

JODIE: enjoyable, informative and thought-provoking — greater appreciation of Indigenous Canadian history — something quite special 3.5⭐️

I really enjoyed Daughters of the Deer. I found it an easy and engaging read, with a well-structured story that drew me in and kept me interested throughout.

I found the historical aspects particularly interesting, especially the insight into the lives, traditions and struggles of Indigenous communities and the impact of colonisation on their families and culture. It made me stop and think about how much of this history I hadn’t known.

I think there is something quite special about an author telling a story connected to her own ancestors and heritage. Writing historical fiction based on such personal history must be a big undertaking, and I thought Danielle Daniel did a good job of bringing these stories to life.

For a debut novel, I think it is a great achievement. It was enjoyable, informative and thought-provoking without being difficult to read. I finished the book feeling glad I’d picked it up and with a greater appreciation of Indigenous Canadian history. Definitely a worthwhile read!

RACHEL: great restraint in letting the truth be enough — gives the reader space — conclusion nicely handled 3.5⭐️

Daughters of the Deer is the second historical fiction novel we’ve read this year that re-imagines the life of a real person. And I think Daniel has completed the task far more respectfully and convincingly than our other read, The Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon.

Marie is an Algonkin woman who accepts a new husband at the request of her chief in the hope of securing a better future for her people. She raises many children, is a healer and gently influences others to value her culture and respect the environment so that it can sustain them. In the 1600s they were noble traits and Daniel shows great restraint in letting the truth be enough, rather than inventing outrageous plot drivers as Ariel Lawhon did.

Daniel has portrayed the life of her ancestors, built the world around them and filled in the gaps as respectfully as possible without resorting to fluff or placing modern day attitudes and personality traits on her characters. I especially enjoyed how she introduced two-spirited people, giving the story topicality but never losing the historical significance, and giving the reader space to form their own connections.

The conclusion is nicely handled. One plot line is given a little padding for reader satisfaction but the villains’ outcomes are treated matter-of-factly without granting them extensive airtime or significance they don’t deserve.

SALLY: characters appropriate for the period — premise was attractive, but I did not enjoy the book — could have drawn us more into the setting 2⭐️

This imagined version of the author’s ancestors’ lives was a great contrast with one of our previous books The Frozen River. The characters were not over-worked and as a result far more appropriate for the period. It’s a tragic story of Indigenous oppression, but weaves in a queer love story between two Algonkin girls and a mixed-race marriage between a French colonial and an Algonkin widow.

The premise was attractive, but I did not enjoy the book. I found the writing stolid and could not connect with the characters. The book is very character heavy and the setting minimal. With native people who are so in tune with their natural world and respectful of it, I thought perhaps the author could have drawn us more into the setting. The theme of colonisers failing to respect the natural world is addressed but would have had more impact if we had been really invested in the flora and fauna surrounding their lives.

I did learn that Algonkin people respected those with diverse identities and sexualities, and were a permissive and tolerant society. Yet another aspect of Indigenous life that European colonisers’ could have learned from but failed.

How wonderful that the author has given life to some of her Algonkin ancestors, just not in a writing style that I enjoyed.

BRIDGET: meandering, thoughtful, quiet — perspective on gender and identity refreshingly open and inclusive — thoroughly enjoyed getting to know each character 3.5⭐️

Daughters Of The Deer is a meandering, thoughtful, and quiet narrative and one I really enjoyed. It is a story that doesn’t feel the need to over-dramatise its characters. Even though the novel is based on real people and historical events, Daniel resists the urge to pad the narrative with unnecessary side plots or unrealistic caricatures. Instead, she grounds the story by writing from the perspectives of three central characters, Pierre, Marie & Jeanne. I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know each of them.

The book dives into some compelling themes. Daniel contrasts what it meant to be Two-Spirit within an Algonkin community, where it was understood and respected, with the harsh condemnation within the French settler community. The Algonkin perspective on gender and identity was refreshingly open and inclusive. It also explores the grim dynamics of the era, where native women in these marriages were treated as a nobody and children were solely the father’s property. Pierre’s character didn’t have an easy road either, his deep love for his wife and children constantly competed with his rigid Catholic faith.

Ultimately, Daniel’s narrative restraint is what makes the book succeed. It’s a beautifully written, understated story about people trying to navigate circumstances beyond their control, which some manage to endure and others do not.

TESSA: easy to read and flows well — strong focus on the loss of culture, identity and traditional ways — author’s family history made it meaningful 4⭐️

I enjoyed this book and found it a moving read. Set in 17th-century Canada, the story follows Marie, an Algonkin healer, and her daughter Jeanne, whose lives are shaped by the arrival of European settlers and the changes this brings to their people.

The first part is told through Marie’s perspective, while the second moves between Marie, Jeanne and Pierre. I thought this worked well, having Pierre’s narration give insight into his thoughts and beliefs as a French settler and his relationship with Marie. Their marriage is not one Marie would have chosen for herself, but one she enters into for the sake of her people.

What I found interesting was the contrast between the Algonkin beliefs and traditions and those imposed by the French settlers, especially around culture, religion and the treatment of women. Jeanne’s story is particularly sad. Her love for another girl would have been accepted within her Mother’s Algonkin culture, but is condemned by the French settlers and the Catholic beliefs imposed on her.

There is a strong focus on the loss of culture, identity and traditional ways of life, as well as the strength of women trying to hold on to their beliefs and protect their families. It also highlights the devastating impact of colonisation and the consequences for Indigenous people.

As a first time novel, I think Danielle Daniel has done a good job. It is very easy to read and flows well, although I did find the writing a little simplistic at times. Knowing that the story is inspired by the author’s family history made it more meaningful for me. I thought it was an important story to tell and it gave me an insight into a part of history that I knew little about. I found it both interesting and engaging, and I’m glad to have read it.


Published 2022
Random House Canada
327 pages

Leave a Reply